Fair Policy, Fair Discussion

June 3, 2010

Aftermath of the Gaza flotilla mission

Activists are returning to their respective countries and funerals are underway for the nine slain activists in Turkey, one of whom was a 19-year-old dual U.S. citizen.  However, the atmosphere of the international community continues to exhibit volatility.

More accounts of the events are pouring in as the activists return. Following the attack, Israel had created an information blackout, barring the captured activists from speaking to media in Israel, but as they return home their stories are emerging.  Bulent Yildrim, the head of the Human Rights and Freedoms and Humanitarian Relief (IHH), said: “I took off my shirt and waved it, as a white flag. We thought they would stop after seeing the white flag, but they continued killing people.”  Norman Paech, a former German politician accounts: “The soldiers were all masked, carrying big guns and were extremely brutal.”  Haneen Zoubi, an Arab-Israeli MP claims Israeli vessels fired on her ship a few minutes before soldiers descended from helicopters.  You can also hear an account of the events from former ambassador and former CNI board member Edward Peck, here.

Israel continues to claim self-defense, and does not take responsibility for the deaths, but feels regretful for them.  “Israel is told it has the right to defend itself, but when we do exercise that right we’re condemned for it… Israel should not be held to a double standard,” says PM Netanyahu.  However, boarding ships in international waters and opening fire on some resistant activists does not seem like defense.  There is a difference between defense and the display of excessive force; wooden batons do not justify the use of rifles.  The activists were on a humanitarian mission, and if they have ties to Islamist organizations, why has Israel sent them back to their own countries instead of detaining them?  How frequently is a nation allowed to commit flagrant violations of international law and oppress people in the name of defense?  Why must the the 1.5 million citizens of Gaza be punished for Israel’s fear of Hamas and Iran?  Denying Gazans their own right to life and security for the sake of Israeli security seems more like a double-standard to me.

Israel is continuing to hold a belligerent attitude towards the international community; ignoring calls to end the blockade in Gaza.  UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said the blockade is “counter-productive, unsustainable and wrong,” and demands a probe from Israel about the raid.  However, progress will never be made as long as the U.S. continues to condone Israel’s behavior.  Special Envoy George Mitchell claims the raid must not undermine indirect peace talks, therefore eliminating any sense of accountability on the part of Israel.   Also, the UN Human Rights Council voted to dispatch its own investigators and have an external inquiry.  I bet you already know who voted against it.

Biden has said Israel has a right to inspect cargo, and “an absolute right to deal with its security interest.”  Along with Obama, he advocates a “transparent and open” Israeli-led investigation.  And although the U.S. realizes the situation in Gaza must be improved, it will not advocate a total end to the blockade in Gaza. The US remains hesitant in reexamining policy.  A White House official claims there is  “a general sense in the administration that it’s time to change our Gaza policy.”  As the U.S. continues to drag its feet, perhaps pressure from the rest of the world will bring an end to U.S. passivity.  Indeed, many protests that emerged against the actions of Israel have also been against the facilitator of those actions.


1 Comment »

  1. this morning ed koch referred to the flotila as “the killa flotila”…he’s assuming the idiots listening to the mark simone radio program are going to come to the conclusion that the israelis did the dying instead of the murdering…everyone and their father is calling for an investigation…i can’t understand why anyone thinks we need an investigation to find out who the good guys are and who the bad guys are…common sense tells me, all we have to do is look at the scorecard…9 flotila members dead, 0 isreali commandos dead…i called the white house message center thursday to urge the president of this fact and hope that he comes to his conclusions on the scorecard alone…whatever happened to the goldstone report? me, personally, i did not need the goldstone report to tell me what the goldstone report said…despite my lack of formal education, common sense alone told me that when the scorecard reads over 1400 palestinians dead, and a score or so of israelis dead; most of them at the hands of friendly-fire, the isrealis not allowing any reporters to report on the ensuing murder spree, invading between christmas and new years, when everyone in washington d.c. is out of town, everyone in america including my family, pre-occupied with entertaining company and shopping for bargains, and no one paying attention to news events, all of the sunday talk shows already taped before the invasion, so no mention of it at all sunday morning…now, the fact that the israelis did not allow any reporters to report on the invasion tells me one of two things; either they were there to deliver cake recipes to the palestinians and they didn’t want the reporters to copy their recipes, or they had pre-meditatedly planned on doing the mexican hat dance on the palestinian heads…again common sense tells me it was the latter…the excuse for the invasion was given as the palestinians were firing rockets into israeli border towns, and that’s all they can stand, and they can’t stand no more, therefore they were forced to invade…according to a november 6th new york times article stating hamas fired dozens of rockets at israel from the gazaa strip on wednesday, “after” israeli forces killed at least five palestinian militants in an eruption of violence that disrupted a four month old truce…the rockets caused no deaths in ashkelon…on 1/4/09, pres.peres said on “this week”, “hamas needs a real serious lesson and they are now getting it”…another classic example of the arrogance of arrogance…does anybody besides me remember the 3200 palestinians slaughtered in 1982, thanks to sharon & co. in lebanon? i also recall reading that no reporters were allowed in the waters where the ss liberty was attacked.
    -carl scala.

    Comment by carl, queens,ny — June 5, 2010 @ 10:07 am | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: