Fair Policy, Fair Discussion

June 17, 2010

Double Standards

Helen Thomas’ misinterpreted remarks about Jews in Palestine led to the end of her accomplished career.  Meanwhile, Senator Schumer of New York is allowed to say he supports the continued “economic strangulation” of Gaza, without anyone even blinking twice.

Schumer is a powerful politician; he is the vice-chairman of the Senate Democratic Caucus, and the third highest ranking Democrat in the Senate.  His position in the government makes the fact that he can make such comments without press coverage or any sort of accountability is especially perturbing.

Schumer, speaking at the Orthodox Union, went on to blame the identity of Palestinians for their situation:  “Palestinian people still don’t believe in the Jewish state, in a two-state solution… They don’t believe in the Torah, in David.” Both of these statements are blatantly false, as most Palestinians support a two-state solution, and Muslims consider the Torah a holy book and David a prophet.  He also blames Gazans for the actions of Hamas, and states that they can only have economic advancement  “when there’s some moderation and cooperation.”

So one of the most powerful senators in the U.S. believes  collective punishment of Palestinians, and denying them a right to livelihood, is justified since they are not Jewish and since Hamas is in power.  Such insensitivity is appalling.  By advocating Palestinian compliance through strangulation, Schumer is effectively denying Palestinians any sort of right to self-determination.  This man is also in a position that enables him to influence policy in the region.

The vast silence after Schumer’s comments either mean that many agree with his views, or there are not many oppositional voices.  Indeed, Jimmy Carter stated that the reluctance “to criticize any policies of the Israeli government is because of the extraordinary lobbying efforts of AIPAC and the absence of any significant contrary voices.” What is needed is more engagement from pro-peace lobbies to counter the power of AIPAC and bigoted voices in Congress.

In addition to CNI, J Street, a pro-Israel and pro-peace lobby, is becoming a formidable challenge to AIPAC.  J Street’s goals are to: “advocate for urgent American diplomatic leadership to achieve a two-state solution and a broader regional, comprehensive peace and, second, to ensure a broad debate on Israel and the Middle East in national politics and the American Jewish community.”  Such new voices are crucial in order to bring different views to Congress and change the political order of Washington.



  1. If advocating a one-state or a two-state end game is OK, it should be permissible to discuss a no-state resolution. The orthodox Jewish sect Neturei Karta supports that position. It doesn’t reflect well on our political discourse that Ms. Thomas wasn’t allowed to do so.

    The no-Jewish-state-in-Palestine position makes sense to the extent that one credits the assertion that Israel is existential danger. There are only about 20 million Jews left in the world. It’s reckless to endanger so many of them.

    Perhaps the USA could arrange for an entity on its territory where Jews could regroup. Something that would combine the autonomy of an Indian reservation or an “associated free state”, with the preferential economic treatment of a special investment zone.

    Comment by Watson — June 19, 2010 @ 12:54 pm | Reply

  2. He’s guilty of anti-Semitism and should be called on it. The Palestinians are Semites, yes?

    Such a simple way to make a very large point that is lost on so many.

    Comment by Julie — June 27, 2010 @ 12:57 am | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: